Comparison of Analgesic Efficacy of Nalbuphine Versus Tramadol as Adjuvant to Local Anaesthetic in Caudal Block in Children
Muhammad Sharif, Muhammad Arif Baloch, Nazeer Ahmed, Zafarullah, Yasir Reda Toble
3458
ABSTRACT
Objective: To compare the mean
time of first analgesia with nalbuphine versus tramadol as adjuvant to
bupivacaine for caudal block in children.
Patients and Methods: In this randomized
clinical trial, a total number of 60 children who were planned for caudal block
after infra-abdominal surgeries having age 3-12 years were included. A caudal
block was performed under general anaesthesia immediately after surgery for
postoperative analgesia. Tramadol 2mg/kg body weight was given caudally to
individuals in group A. Group B patients had 0.125 percent bupivacaine with
0.1mg/kg nalbuphine caudally. Time of requirement of first analgesia was noted
in all patients. Paracetamol 10 mg/kg was given as rescue analgesic in all
patients.
Results: Mean age of patients
was 8.30±3.03 years. Mean weight of patients was 23.33±6.92 Kg. There were 26
(43.33%) female patients and 34 (56.67%) male patients. There were 50 (83.33%)
children who were having ASA status I, and remaining 10 (16.67%) children were
having ASA status II. Mean pain score was 3.53±1.43 in tramadol group and
1.86±1.25 in Nalbuphine group (p-value <0.001. Mean time of first rescue
analgesia was significantly prolonged in Nalbuphine group, mean time was 6.13±1.07
hours in Nalbuphine group versus 4.03±1.03 hours in tramadol group (p-value
<0.001).
Conclusion: Single dose of
nalbuphine as an adjunct to bupivacaine is superior as compared to tramadol in
reducing the post-operative pain, it also significantly prolongs the duration
of analgesia in children.
Keywords: Caudal Block,
Nalbuphine, Tramadol, Post-operative pain, Time of first rescue analgesia.