Outcome Assessment of Comparison between Surgical Decompression versus Local Corticosteroid Injection in Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
Mirza Muhammad Khurram Shazad, Muhammad Rizwan, Muhammad Irfan Ul Haq Khawaja, Abdul Rasheed Napar, Awais Amjad
177
ABSTRACT
Aim: To evaluate
the effectiveness of surgical decompression versus local corticosteroids for carpal tunnel syndrome in improving clinical outcome and
to determine the length of symptom relief
Study Design: This was a comparative, longitudinal and interventional study.
Place and duration of study: OPD and A&E department of Orthopedics Surgery and Traumatology
(DOST) Unit I, King Edward Medical University/ Mayo Hospital Lahore. duration
of study was 1 year after approval of synopsis.
Methodology: Cases of carpel tunnel syndrome with age 18 years and above were
included. The diagnosis of carpel tunnel syndrome was based on general physical
examination, nerve conduction studies and additional radiological test.). A
total 64 patients were selected randomly. They were divided into two groups. GROUP
“A” was treated by surgical decompression. Group “B” was treated by local
corticosteroids. They were follow up at 3 months, 6 months and 1 year. All the
procedures were done by single surgical team. Outcome measuring tools
symptom severity scale(CTS) and
functional status scale (CTS) were used.
Results: In
group A and B the mean age of patients was 45.44±8.39 and 47.22±9.72 years respectively. Mean symptoms
severity scale in group-A was higher when compared to group-B at 3 months, 6
month and 1 year with p-value < 0.05. Moreover mean functional severity
scale was also improved in group-A when compared to group-B at 3 month, 6 month
and 1 year with p-value < 0.05.
Conclusion: Through this study we conclude that surgical decompression of carpal
tunnel versus local corticosteroid injection in terms of clinical outcome
improvement and to assess the length of symptomatic relief.
Keywords
Hand surgery, carpel tunnel syndrome,
conservative treatment, steroid injection, surgical decompression
ABSTRACT
Aim: To evaluate
the effectiveness of surgical decompression versus local corticosteroids for carpal tunnel syndrome in improving clinical outcome and
to determine the length of symptom relief
Study Design: This was a comparative, longitudinal and interventional study.
Place and duration of study: OPD and A&E department of Orthopedics Surgery and Traumatology
(DOST) Unit I, King Edward Medical University/ Mayo Hospital Lahore. duration
of study was 1 year after approval of synopsis.
Methodology: Cases of carpel tunnel syndrome with age 18 years and above were
included. The diagnosis of carpel tunnel syndrome was based on general physical
examination, nerve conduction studies and additional radiological test.). A
total 64 patients were selected randomly. They were divided into two groups. GROUP
“A” was treated by surgical decompression. Group “B” was treated by local
corticosteroids. They were follow up at 3 months, 6 months and 1 year. All the
procedures were done by single surgical team. Outcome measuring tools
symptom severity scale(CTS) and
functional status scale (CTS) were used.
Results: In
group A and B the mean age of patients was 45.44±8.39 and 47.22±9.72 years respectively. Mean symptoms
severity scale in group-A was higher when compared to group-B at 3 months, 6
month and 1 year with p-value < 0.05. Moreover mean functional severity
scale was also improved in group-A when compared to group-B at 3 month, 6 month
and 1 year with p-value < 0.05.
Conclusion: Through this study we conclude that surgical decompression of carpal
tunnel versus local corticosteroid injection in terms of clinical outcome
improvement and to assess the length of symptomatic relief.
Keywords
Hand surgery, carpel tunnel syndrome,
conservative treatment, steroid injection, surgical decompression