Comparison of Phase 1 Cardiac Rehabilitation with and without Lower Limb Paddling Effects in Post-CABG Patients
Muhammad Faizan Hamid, Qurrat-Ul-Ain Nazar, Nahrat Kumar Alias Akash, Zubair Khalid, Maria Shaukat Ali, A. Farooqi, H. Rana M. Arslan
342
ABSTRACT
Objective: To compare the
effectiveness of Phase 1 cardiac rehabilitation with lower limb paddling, with
phase 1 cardiac rehabilitation without lower limb paddling.
Study Design: Randomized clinical
Trail
Place and Duration of Study: Department
of Cardiology, Rawal General and Dental Hospital Islamabad from 1st
January 2020 to 31st December 2020.
Methodology: Fifty four patients, 27 in each group were
determined using general self-efficacy before intervention readings. Inclusion
was made on post elective Sternotomy surgery, post extubation, both genders,
age between 35 and 60 years, body mass index (BMI) between 20 and 30 kg/m2,
hemodynamic stability, absence of arrhythmias.
Results: The mean SF-36 at day
1 was 37.74±1.45 and at Day 7 was 90.42±11.8 in experimental group and
37.22±1.45 at Day 1 and 76.81±2.58 at day 7 for control group respectively. The
mean FIM at day 1 was 31.48±5.07 and on day 7 it was 109.03±5.97 in experimental
group compared to 33.66±5.34 on day 1, and 82.44±13.35 on day 7 for controls.
The mean for self-efficacy at day 1 was 19.11±2.5 and at day 7 it was
62.59±3.17 in experimental compared to 21.11±3.59 on day 1, and 61.74±6.32 on
day 7 in the controls. The mean EF was same at day 1 and day 7, in experimental
group it was 53.11±4.8 whereas for control group it was 53.85±3.76 one day 1
and day 7. The mean ABGs at day 1 were 7.41±0.05 and at Day 7 it was 7.42±0.04
in experimental group whereas in the controls it was 7.39±0.39 at Day 1 and
7.44±0.01 at day 7.
Conclusion: Phase 1 cardiac
rehabilitation with and without paddling have similar effects according to ABGs
and Ejection fraction. However, the quality of life was found significantly
improved using paddling intervention during Phase 1 Cardiac rehabilitation
compared to those without paddling. Hence it is implied that it is safe to
incorporate paddling with phase 1 cardiac rehabilitation in post CABG patients.
Keywords: Coronary
artery disease, Cardiac rehabilitation, CABG, Ergometer