Opting to Stay in the Pakistan or Abroad; A Cross Sectional Survey of Tow Public and Private Medical Colleges
Sheena Mustafa, Sadia Rashid, Najma Bano Shaikh, Saba Khan, Samina Ayaz, Shazia Aftab
789
ABSTRACT
Objective: To determine the reasons of opting to stay in the Pakistan
or abroad between students of tow public and private medical colleges.
Materials and Methods: Descriptive cross-sectional, questionnaire-based study was
conducted in a Private and Public sector medical college in Karachi from
October to November 2018. A sample of 400 medical students 200 from each
college, 40 students (20 males; 20 females) from each of first to final (5th)
year batches separately were selected randomly. Study protocol was approved by
the Ethical Review Committee of DUHS while permission for data collection on a
questioner of 16 items was sought from authorities of both Medical Colleges.
Data were entered & analyzed into SPSS version 26.
Results: The mean age of students was 22.18 ± 1.788 years. Father of
20.3% (n=81) and the mother of 12.8% (n=51) students were MBBS, or BDS and
almost all of them were practicing. It was found that with the increasing
age / class year preference of working in Pakistan (and UK) increased (Up to
1.5 times; p value < 0.380). Likewise; females prefer Pakistan, UK and Gulf
countries more than males who had Pakistan and USA top preference to medicine
career in the future (P value = 0.758). Although abroad preference was
statically significant among private university student (P value = 0.001).
Conclusion: Private university medical students were more observed for
opting the foreign countries mostly UK and USA compared to the government
Medical University students. Financial Reward, life-Style and job Opportunities
were observed the commonest reasons. The lack of career counselling and
guideline results in health industry losing many future doctors every year as
well as loss of potential resources on their training.
Keywords: Medical
Education, Motivational factors, Emigration
ABSTRACT
Objective: To determine the reasons of opting to stay in the Pakistan
or abroad between students of tow public and private medical colleges.
Materials and Methods: Descriptive cross-sectional, questionnaire-based study was
conducted in a Private and Public sector medical college in Karachi from
October to November 2018. A sample of 400 medical students 200 from each
college, 40 students (20 males; 20 females) from each of first to final (5th)
year batches separately were selected randomly. Study protocol was approved by
the Ethical Review Committee of DUHS while permission for data collection on a
questioner of 16 items was sought from authorities of both Medical Colleges.
Data were entered & analyzed into SPSS version 26.
Results: The mean age of students was 22.18 ± 1.788 years. Father of
20.3% (n=81) and the mother of 12.8% (n=51) students were MBBS, or BDS and
almost all of them were practicing. It was found that with the increasing
age / class year preference of working in Pakistan (and UK) increased (Up to
1.5 times; p value < 0.380). Likewise; females prefer Pakistan, UK and Gulf
countries more than males who had Pakistan and USA top preference to medicine
career in the future (P value = 0.758). Although abroad preference was
statically significant among private university student (P value = 0.001).
Conclusion: Private university medical students were more observed for
opting the foreign countries mostly UK and USA compared to the government
Medical University students. Financial Reward, life-Style and job Opportunities
were observed the commonest reasons. The lack of career counselling and
guideline results in health industry losing many future doctors every year as
well as loss of potential resources on their training.
Keywords: Medical
Education, Motivational factors, Emigration