Comparison of Transverse Cancellous Lag Screw and Ordinary Cannulated Screw Fixations in Treatment of Vertical Femoral Neck Fractures
Mohamed Abdel Rahman, Haytham Abdelazim, Sherif Ishak, Ahmed A. Desoky
1191
ABSTRACT
Aim of the Work: To
compare the clinical therapeutic effect of transverse cancellous lag screw
(TCLS) fixations and ordinary cannulated screw (OCS) fixations for vertical
femoral neck fractures.
Patients and Methods: This prospective randomized controlled study was
conducted in Ain Shams University hospitals
and El-Zaitoun hospital in Cairo. It included twenty two cases, who sustained femoral
neck fractures.
Patients were divided into 2 groups; Group A: using ordinary cannulated screws as a method of
fixation. Group B: using
transverse lag screws as a method of fixation. A randomized controlled study
involved twenty two cases, who complained of fracture neck femur femoral neck
fractures.
Results: There was statistically significant slightly improved
in TCLS group compared to OCS group. The results showed 5 patients out of 22 having complications, 2 patients (18.2%) belong to TCLS Group compared to 3
patients (27.3%) belong to OCS group,
with avascular Necrosis 1 patient (9.1%) in TCLS regarding Neck Shortening 1
patient (9.1%) in TCLS and 2 patients (18.2%) OCS group. Regarding Non Union 1
patient (9.1%) in OCS group, there were high complications in OCS group
compared to TCLS group but insignificant.
Conclusion: A new study suggests that using
the TCLS method to treat vertical femoral neck fractures may improve hip
function and reduce neck shortening rates. Type III femoral neck fractures in
Pauwels patients may benefit from this study's findings.
Keywords: transverse
cancellous lag screw, ordinary cannulated screw, fixation, vertical femoral neck,
fractures
ABSTRACT
Aim of the Work: To
compare the clinical therapeutic effect of transverse cancellous lag screw
(TCLS) fixations and ordinary cannulated screw (OCS) fixations for vertical
femoral neck fractures.
Patients and Methods: This prospective randomized controlled study was
conducted in Ain Shams University hospitals
and El-Zaitoun hospital in Cairo. It included twenty two cases, who sustained femoral
neck fractures.
Patients were divided into 2 groups; Group A: using ordinary cannulated screws as a method of
fixation. Group B: using
transverse lag screws as a method of fixation. A randomized controlled study
involved twenty two cases, who complained of fracture neck femur femoral neck
fractures.
Results: There was statistically significant slightly improved
in TCLS group compared to OCS group. The results showed 5 patients out of 22 having complications, 2 patients (18.2%) belong to TCLS Group compared to 3
patients (27.3%) belong to OCS group,
with avascular Necrosis 1 patient (9.1%) in TCLS regarding Neck Shortening 1
patient (9.1%) in TCLS and 2 patients (18.2%) OCS group. Regarding Non Union 1
patient (9.1%) in OCS group, there were high complications in OCS group
compared to TCLS group but insignificant.
Conclusion: A new study suggests that using
the TCLS method to treat vertical femoral neck fractures may improve hip
function and reduce neck shortening rates. Type III femoral neck fractures in
Pauwels patients may benefit from this study's findings.
Keywords: transverse
cancellous lag screw, ordinary cannulated screw, fixation, vertical femoral neck,
fractures